A federal judge on Thursday cleared the way for the majority of President Donald Trump’s defamation case against the New York Times and publisher Penguin Random House to move forward, handing Trump a procedural victory in his broader legal campaign against media outlets he says treated him unfairly.
The suit, one of several that Trump has filed against media companies since 2024 alleging defamation or fraudulent public misrepresentation, targets two Times articles and a book produced by Times journalists. The complaint characterized those materials as "false, malicious, defamatory, and disparaging" and said they were intended to undermine his prospects in the 2024 presidential election, which he won.
Representatives for the New York Times, Penguin Random House and Trump’s personal lawyers did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday, a George H.W. Bush appointee, issued the ruling in federal court in Tampa, Florida. According to the ruling, two of Trump’s claims were dismissed, but the remainder of the complaint sufficiently alleged that certain statements accusing Trump of "planning and perpetrating complex crimes" were based on "incomplete, minimal information." Merryday found those remaining allegations plausible enough to survive a motion to dismiss.
The lawsuit focuses on a book by New York Times journalist Peter Baker titled "For Trump, a Lifetime of Scandals Heads Toward a Moment of Judgment" and on two articles by Times reporters Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner. In total, the complaint cites 22 statements from the book and 12 statements from the articles.
Those cited passages challenge elements of Trump’s public narrative as a self-made businessman and entertainment figure. They touch on his role in developing the television show "The Apprentice," the size and nature of any inheritance from his father, various business ventures and details of his upbringing in New York City.
In filings seeking dismissal, the Times and Penguin argued that the complaint fails to demonstrate how the challenged statements are defamatory. They contended many of the passages are expressions of subjective opinion or commentary that cannot be proven true or false, and therefore are not actionable as defamation under the law.
The court’s ruling does not resolve the merits of the defamation claims. Rather, by allowing most of the case to proceed past an early-stage dismissal motion, the judge determined that some of the pleaded allegations were sufficiently specific and plausible to warrant further litigation.
The litigation sits among a series of suits that Trump has brought against media organizations since 2024. Critics of those legal actions describe them as attacks on the free press; supporters say they are legitimate legal responses to allegedly false reporting. The New York Times and Penguin maintain their reporting and publications do not defame Trump.
At this stage, the case will move into subsequent phases of litigation, where factual development and legal arguments will determine whether the remaining claims can survive to trial or be resolved on other grounds.